Advertisment Disclaimer

We maintain complete transparency with the readers on our website. The company rankings on our site are independent of any marketing relationships that we may hold with a home warranty company. We may receive compensation for receiving quotes or placing advertisements. However, this does not affect a company's rankings. Companies are ranked solely on the basis of consumer reviews and ratings received from home warranty users.

last_updated_icon Last updated: July 31, 2020


city icon CITY: Evansville
country icon COUNTRY: Vanderburgh County
state icon STATE: IN
zipcode icon ZIP CODES COVERED: 47701, 47702, 47703, 47704, 47705,
population icon POPULATION: 182901
area code icon AREA CODE: 812

on Home Warranty plans!

$150 OFF and 1 MONTH FREE!

Get expert technicians to care for your home at unbeatable prices

Total Home Protection presents

Total Home Protection presents

$100 OFF and 2 MONTHS FREE!

Now to avail this offer use code : THS100


Top Rated

American Home Shield (AHS)

4.5 / 5
(13,305 Reviews )

They are the pioneers in the home warranty industry. The company has 15,000 licensed technicians nationwide. AHS plans come into effect 30 days after the date of purchase and lasts for 12 months.

Best in service

The Home Service Club

4.5 / 5
(1,626 Reviews )

The company was founded in 2008. They have a vast network of skilled contractors and dedicated customer support representatives who offer high-quality services. HSC plans come into effect within ten days following the payment. 

Choice Home Warranty

4.1 / 5
(6,732 Reviews )

The company has been in the industry for over 11 years. Since their inception, they have protected more than 1,000,000 homes across the United States. The company offers a range of plans that cover major appliances and systems. 

Select Home Warranty

4.1 / 5
(4,299 Reviews )

They are the only company in the home warranty industry to offer coverage for mobile homes. They offer a 30-day free trial and $100 Off on roof coverage. Select Home Warranty has a dedicated team that offers 24/7 customer support. 

Total Home Protection

4.6 / 5
(681 Reviews )

hey are the leading home warranty provider in the industry. They have skilled and licensed technicians who top-notch services. A standout feature of their services is they do not require a home inspection.

evansville Home Warranty Companies Reviews


Monica Ramirez, Evansville

On Jun 17, 2020

American Home Shield (AHS)

We had a wonderful experience recently! Our hot water went out on Sunday night around 10 PM so I submitted a request and heard back from a plumber less than 16 hours later, he came out that day to diagnose the problem, and then came back the following day to replace our water heater. So it took less than 48 hours to get our home back in working order! We were very happy and American home shield replaced our water heater and we paid for the service call and some piping that we needed but to us that wasn’t a big deal and we understood that it was mostly the major systems in the house that were covered under warranty and we were so glad the warranty replaced the heater and installation!


Anthony Givens, Evansville

On Apr 28, 2020

American Home Shield (AHS)

Sink went bad at the same time our water heater went out during the Covid19 stay at home order. This was a time when every modern convenience was at a premium, plus hot water is utilized to clean and disinfect many surfaces, areas and our own personage. To say the least, I was in hot water with no hot water. Nonetheless AHS came through on all counts, and restored a sense of normalcy in a chaotic time.


Anthony Dunn, Evansville

On Jun 07, 2019

American Home Shield (AHS)

A/C condenser fan wasn\'t working properly. They got thier, troubleshoot it fairly quick. Determined the problem and order the new fan motor and blade. Was back in a couple of days and repaired it when I wasn\'t home. Overall great service.


Amber Winters, Evansville

On Apr 11, 2018

American Home Shield (AHS)

Service is always completed within 48 hours. There have been issues with certain companies, but they are resolved quickly and they listen to the survey reviews after the service. It is worth the money. I have had to have my dishwasher fixed which would have been 300$ which I paid 75. One month after moving in my hot water heater went out and it was replaced for 75$.


Erin , Evansville

On Aug 29, 2017

American Home Shield (AHS)

It took 2 entire summers and multiple calls to get my air conditioner properly repaired. The first contractor left a leak. I paid for it to be charged twice because the warranty company didn\'t cover the charge. The second company was able to find the leak, repair the leak, and charge the unit which is now working fine. It is extremely difficult to get ahold of customer service. The sales people answer immediately, but good luck getting anyone on the line when you have a claim. I waited months for the original contractor every time he was supposed to come fix the unit only to find out he did not install it properly leading to additional charges in chemicals because of the leak.


Amber, Evansville

On Jun 12, 2017

American Home Shield (AHS)

Usually have someone out in 24-48 hours after entering service request. Providers are nice, but sometimes not timely. Would recommend!


Angela Trice, Evansville

On May 31, 2016

American Home Shield (AHS)

We recently had two appliances break down within a couple of days of each other. Both companies were super quick to reach out and schedule the appointment. I found both service people to be professional, timely, and courteous.


Laura Lockyear, Evansville

On Sep 05, 2014

American Home Shield (AHS)

I can't imagine owning a home without American Home Shield. It gives me the peace of mind I need knowing that if I have an issue with an appliance or a system, American Home Shield is there to fix it or replace it for such a minimal cost. I simply could not be a homeowner without it. I purchased a 1935 bungalow with a 25 year-old A/C unit. A year after being in the house, it went out. Thankfully, I had AHS. They made arrangements for a local repairman to assess the problem. It was determined the compressor had gone out on the unit and could not be fixed. Within 3 days, I had a brand new unit. My total out of pocket cost was $142. Being a single mother with a son in college, I am thankful every hot summer day for having American Home Shield.