Home Warranty Company Ratings and Comparison

Compare and choose among the best rated home warranty companies. These Independent reviews and ratings are collected from customers who have used the service before.

Home Warranty Plans

   
How are companies ranked?
American_Home_Shield_(AHS) 2016 top rated
Premium    $249 - $500+
Deductible  $75 - $125
Rating       4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating
Effective     -   At closing or 15 days
Add to Compare
The_Home_Service_Club 2016 best in service
Premium    $400
Deductible  $65 - $125
Rating       4.5 Star Rating4.5 Star Rating4.5 Star Rating4.5 Star Rating4.5 Star Rating4.5 Star Rating
Effective     -   Depends on the policy
Add to Compare
Secure_Home_Warranty
Premium    $319-$499
Deductible  $45
Rating       4.5 Star Rating4.5 Star Rating4.5 Star Rating4.5 Star Rating4.5 Star Rating4.5 Star Rating
Effective     -   30 days from payment
Add to Compare
Select_Home_Warranty
Premium    $299 - $499
Deductible  $60
Rating       4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating
Effective     -   30 days from purchase
Add to Compare
First_American_Home_Buyers_Protection
Premium    $288-$468
Deductible  $65-$75
Rating       3.5 Star Rating3.5 Star Rating3.5 Star Rating3.5 Star Rating3.5 Star Rating3.5 Star Rating
Effective     -   30 days after enrollment
Add to Compare
America's_Preferred_Home_Warranty-APHW
Premium    $400 - $565
Deductible  $75-$125
Rating       4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating
Effective     -   Closing or 30 days from payment
Add to Compare
HSA_Home_Warranty
Premium    $589-$619
Deductible  $75-$100
Rating       4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating
Effective     -   At closing or 30 days after enrollment for existing homeowners
Add to Compare
Landmark_Home_Warranty 2016 best regional co.
Premium    $425 - $625
Deductible  $60
Rating       4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating
Effective     -   At closing or 30 days
Add to Compare
Home_Warranty_Of_America
Premium    $300 - $369
Deductible  $60 - $100
Rating       3.5 Star Rating3.5 Star Rating3.5 Star Rating3.5 Star Rating3.5 Star Rating3.5 Star Rating
Effective     -   Date of order or the closing date
Add to Compare
2-10_Home_Buyers_Warranty
Premium    $305-$600
Deductible  $60-$100
Rating       3.5 Star Rating3.5 Star Rating3.5 Star Rating3.5 Star Rating3.5 Star Rating3.5 Star Rating
Effective     -   Immediate at closing or 30 days after enrollment for existing homeowners
Add to Compare
Choice_Home_Warranty
Premium    $370 - $450
Deductible  $60
Rating       3.5 Star Rating3.5 Star Rating3.5 Star Rating3.5 Star Rating3.5 Star Rating3.5 Star Rating
Effective     -   30 days after enrollment
Add to Compare
Total_Protect
Premium    $350 - $650
Deductible  $75 - $125
Rating       3 Star Rating3 Star Rating3 Star Rating3 Star Rating3 Star Rating3 Star Rating
Effective     -   30 days after enrollment
Add to Compare
365_Home_Warranty
Premium    $349-$549
Deductible  $75
Rating       4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating
Effective     -   30 days after enrollment
Add to Compare
Delta_Home_Protect
Premium    $498
Deductible  $75
Rating       4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating
Effective     -   30 days
Add to Compare
American_Home_Guardian
Premium    $359 - $570
Deductible  $60
Rating       4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating4 Star Rating
Effective     -   At closing or 30 days from purchase
Add to Compare
Blue_Ribbon_Home_Warranty
Premium    $399
Deductible  $55
Rating       3.5 Star Rating3.5 Star Rating3.5 Star Rating3.5 Star Rating3.5 Star Rating3.5 Star Rating
Effective     -   At closing for buyers; upon accepting application for sellers & homeowners.
Add to Compare
HMS_Home_Warranty
Premium    $360-$500+
Deductible  $50 - $100
Rating       2.5 Star Rating2.5 Star Rating2.5 Star Rating2.5 Star Rating2.5 Star Rating2.5 Star Rating
Effective     -   Immediate with a Real Estate Transaction
Add to Compare
Old_Republic_Home_Warranty
Premium    $260-$500
Deductible  $55-$100
Rating       2 Star Rating2 Star Rating2 Star Rating2 Star Rating2 Star Rating2 Star Rating
Effective     -   At closing or 30 days after enrollment for existing homeowners
Add to Compare
AFC_-_Americas_First_Choice
Premium    $440
Deductible  $60
Rating       3 Star Rating3 Star Rating3 Star Rating3 Star Rating3 Star Rating3 Star Rating
Effective     -   30 days from enrollment
Add to Compare
Complete_Appliance_Protection
Premium    $380 - $720
Deductible  $0
Rating       4.5 Star Rating4.5 Star Rating4.5 Star Rating4.5 Star Rating4.5 Star Rating4.5 Star Rating
Effective     -   Closing or after 30 days
Add to Compare
Fidelity_National_Home_Warranty
Premium    $350-$445
Deductible  $55
Rating       2 Star Rating2 Star Rating2 Star Rating2 Star Rating2 Star Rating2 Star Rating
Effective     -   upon payment receipt
Add to Compare
OneGuard_Home_Warranties
Premium    $396-$500
Deductible  $60-$79
Rating       2.5 Star Rating2.5 Star Rating2.5 Star Rating2.5 Star Rating2.5 Star Rating2.5 Star Rating
Effective     -   Closing or 30 days after payment
Add to Compare
American_Residential_Warranty
Premium    $402
Deductible  $50
Rating       2 Star Rating2 Star Rating2 Star Rating2 Star Rating2 Star Rating2 Star Rating
Effective     -   30 days after enrollment
Add to Compare
Allied_Home_Warranty
Premium    $395-$600
Deductible  $60
Rating       2 Star Rating2 Star Rating2 Star Rating2 Star Rating2 Star Rating2 Star Rating
Effective     -   Date of order or closing
Add to Compare
Helping_American_Homeowners_Association
Premium    $250-$750+
Deductible  $100
Rating       4.5 Star Rating4.5 Star Rating4.5 Star Rating4.5 Star Rating4.5 Star Rating4.5 Star Rating
Effective     -   Effective date after paid
Add to Compare


Looking for more? Request for a new company to be added OR check out companies that have gone out of business.

Want to know more about our ranking process? Check How do we rank Home Warranty Companies.

Please be advised that customers who are dissatisfied with their home warranty program are more likely to voice their opinion than those who had no complaints. So, you will see more negative reviews here than positive ones.

Another reason for dissatisfaction is that some consumers realize that the warranty would not cover pre-existing and lack-of-maintenance problems only after they file a claim. Home warranty companies are listed below. Choose the offer that fits your needs and get a price quote before buy the insurance policy.


Notes and Disclaimers
  1. The weighted average sorting uses an advanced Bayesian weighting formula, listings with just a few positive ratings won't outrank those with many high ratings and a few negatives.
  2. This is not an extensive list of providers. Please check your local listings to find out about the coverage in your area.
  3. Premium and deductible pricing info was taken from internet resources and maybe outdated. Please call insurance provides for latest pricing info
  4. Neither do we endorse any of the providers, nor do we get paid by them. We try our best to keep the information unbiased.
  5. Check out FAQs section if you have questions about our approval policy