We maintain complete transparency with the readers on our website. The company rankings on our site are independent of any marketing relationships that we may hold with a home warranty company. We may receive compensation for receiving quotes or placing advertisements. However, this does not affect a company's rankings. Companies are ranked solely on the basis of consumer reviews and ratings received from home warranty users.

*The lead information obtained will be sent to the respective companies as selected by the readers. However, the lead will be shared with a similar company if the selected company either doesn't participate in Leads Program or doesn't respond.

Home /  Home Maintenance / Factors Affecting The Garage Door Repair & Replacement Cost
last_updated_date Last updated: December 15th, 2023

Factors Affecting The Garage Door Repair & Replacement Cost

Image Depicting A Before & After Garage Door Replacement

Do you know that, on average, a garage door opens and closes 3-5 times daily? That means it goes through approximately 1,500 cycles each year. Yes! Garage doors play a crucial role in our daily lives, providing convenient access to our homes and ensuring the safety and security of our vehicles and belongings.

However, like any other machine, garage doors have a limited lifespan. While regular maintenance can help keep them in optimal condition, wear and tear is inevitable after years of use. So, if you’re a garage owner wanting to improve the garage doors, you’ve come to the right place. 

In this article, we’ll explore garage door replacement costs, factors affecting it, and some expert tips to help you save bucks on replacement. 

Common Garage Door Issues

Knowing the common issues that can impede your garage doors can help you foresee potential problems and be prepared with ideal solutions.

Image Displaying The Garage Door And Most Common Garage Door Issues That Homeowners Might Face.

Here are the top five garage door problems that homeowners frequently face. 

  • Broken Springs: A Major Cause of Concern
    One of the most frequent issues with garage doors is broken springs. These balance the door’s weight, making it easy to open and close. When a spring breaks, it can pose a severe safety hazard, as the door may become unstable and difficult to manage.
    If you notice a broken spring, it is crucial to seek professional assistance immediately to prevent any injuries or further damage.
  • Blocked Sensors: Easy to Fix
    Garage door sensors detect any obstruction in the path of the closing door and prevent it from closing, thereby avoiding accidents or damage. However, sensors can sometimes become blocked or misaligned, causing the door to malfunction. 
    To address this issue, carefully inspect the sensors and remove any dirt, debris, or obstructions. If the problem persists, it is advisable to consult a garage door professional for further assistance.
  • Trouble Opening/Closing: Identify the Culprit
    If you struggle to open or close your garage door smoothly, several factors could be causing the problem. First, check the tracks and rollers for any dirt, grime, or damage hindering their movement. 
    Clean the tracks regularly and lubricate the rollers using a silicone-based lubricant to ensure proper functioning. Additionally, inspect the cables and springs for any signs of wear and tear. If you need help or if the issue persists, it is recommended that you contact a professional technician.
  • Unusual Noises: Listen Carefully
    Unusual noises coming from your garage door can be concerning. These noises can range from squeaking and grinding to banging or screeching sounds. In most cases, they indicate a worn or damaged component that requires attention.
    Search for various moving parts, such as hinges, tracks, and springs, to address this issue. Tighten any loose screws or bolts and lubricate the components as needed. However, if the noise persists, it is advisable to seek professional help to prevent further damage.
  • Uneven Door: Alignment Issues
    An uneven garage door can be aesthetically displeasing and lead to functionality issues. Over time, factors such as temperature changes, wear and tear, or accidental bumps can cause the tracks to become misaligned.
    Inspect the tracks carefully and gently tap them back into place if necessary. However, it is best to consult a professional for guidance if you need clarification or encounter difficulties during the process.
    So, is your garage door showing signs of wear and tear? Some issues may be easy to identify and fix, but some problems may require replacing your garage door. Pay attention to the following warning signs! 

    1. Door Sagging
    2. Repeated Excessive Noise
    3. Cracked/Damaged wooden doors
    4. Aged/Old Door

It may be time to get a new garage door if you notice any of these signs. Let’s learn about the replacement costs and factors that may affect the pricing. 

Factors Affecting Garage Door Replacement Costs

A study reveals that a new garage door offers significant returns on investment when undertaking home improvement projects. So, it’s crucial to invest in the right garage door, and to do so, it is essential to understand the factors that affect the investment. 

Infographic Mentioning The Main Factors Affecting Garage Door Replacement Costs

From the size and style of the door to the type of material used, each element plays a significant role in determining the final price of your new garage door. Let’s look at the three most important factors in the section below. 

  • Size of the door
    The size of the garage door is one of the primary determinants of replacement costs. Different sizes require varying amounts of material and labor, resulting in a price difference. As per the industry average, a standard single-car garage door is around 8-9 ft. wide and 7-8 ft. high, costing between $500 and $2500. On the other hand, a standard double-door garage is 16 feet wide and 7 to 8 feet high. A 2-single garage door can cost around $2,300 on average. It can get even more expensive if you choose to go for three single garage doors, which can go up to $7,000. 
  • Style of the door
    Garage doors are available in various styles, with each style contributing to the overall cost. The style chosen can enhance the home’s curb appeal and impact the final price. Some popular garage door styles include:



Replacement Cost


These doors bring a touch of traditional elegance to any home and often feature decorative handles and hinges. The intricate design and additional detailing can increase the overall replacement cost.

Up to $4,000

French Style

French garage doors are known for their charm and sophistication. These doors typically have windows to allow natural light into the garage. 

The inclusion of glass panels and the requirement for specialized installation can make French-style doors more expensive to replace. 

Up to $6,000

Glass Roll-Up

Glass roll-up doors provide a modern and sleek look to any property. These doors are constructed with glass panels and aluminum frames, offering a unique aesthetic appeal. 

Up to $4,500


Roll-up garage doors are a popular choice for their durability and practicality. They require minimal space and operate smoothly with the help of tracks and rollers. 

Due to their simplicity in design, roll-up doors tend to have lower replacement costs

Starting from $800

Standard Panel

Standard panel doors are characterized by their simplicity and versatility. These doors have multiple horizontal panels, allowing for customization and various design options.

$500 to $2,000.


Tilt-up garage doors operate by tilting upward and then sliding into the garage. These doors offer a classic and timeless look.

$500 – $2,500


Walk-through garage doors provide convenience by allowing pedestrian access without opening the entire door. These doors typically feature a smaller door integrated into the main garage door.

Up to $3,000

Note: These are average costs per the market rates and may differ according to location. 

  • Type of Door Material
    The door’s material is another factor that influences the cost, and you might be surprised by the numerous available material options. The most common ones are aluminum, steel, fiberglass, vinyl, faux wood, and wood. Each material has its own unique characteristics, advantages, and price considerations.  Some typical materials used for garage doors are mentioned in the table below. Take a look:

Material Type


Replacement Cost


Steel garage doors are durable, low-maintenance, and provide excellent security. They are available in various styles and textures. The cost of replacing a steel door is based on insulation, thickness, and design complexity.

$600 to $2,000


Aluminum garage doors are lightweight, resistant to rust, and offer a sleek appearance. They are a popular choice for modern or contemporary homes. Replacement costs for aluminum doors are typically lower compared to other materials.

$600 – $900

Faux Wood

Faux wood garage doors mimic the appearance of real wood but require less maintenance and offer better durability. 

These doors are available in various finishes and can add a touch of elegance to any home. The cost of replacing faux wood doors depends on the quality and specific design features.

Up to $5000


Fiberglass garage doors are lightweight, durable, and resistant to dents. They are also available in a range of styles and colors. 

While the upfront cost of fiberglass doors tends to be higher, their longevity and low maintenance requirements can result in long-term cost savings.

Up to $4,500


Vinyl garage doors are known for their exceptional durability and resistance to harsh weather conditions. 

They require minimal maintenance and are available in various colors and styles. The cost of replacing vinyl doors is based on the insulation and the complexity of the design.

$1,000 – $2,600,

Note: This is the average pricing per the market rates and may differ according to your location. 

Additional Factors Affecting Garage Door Replacement Costs

Apart from the style, design, and material type, you will also have to consider the following:

 Image Depicting All The Additional Factors Impacting The Garage Door Replacement Costs

  • Labor
    Labor is one factor that can massively influence the garage door replacement cost. Depending on your location, the average cost can range between $200 to $500.
  • Manual v/s Automatic door
    One of the primary decisions when replacing a garage door is whether to opt for a manual or an automatic door. While manual doors may initially cost less, they require more effort to open and close.  On the other hand, automatic doors offer convenience with features like remote control operation and safety sensors. However, the convenience of automatic doors often comes with a higher price tag.
  • Electrical work
    In the case of an automatic garage door, electrical work is a crucial consideration. Depending on your existing electrical setup, you may need to hire a licensed electrician to install the necessary wiring and outlets. This additional electrical work can contribute to the overall cost of replacing your garage door.
  • Windows
    Adding windows to your garage door can significantly enhance its aesthetics and functionality. Windows allow natural light to enter, creating a brighter and more inviting space. However, adding windows can also impact the replacement cost by 70%. The number, size, and type of windows you choose will influence the project’s overall cost.
  • Brand of the door
    Different brands offer varying levels of quality, durability, and warranties. While reputable brands may come with a higher price tag, they often provide superior performance and longer lifespan. When selecting a garage door brand, it is crucial to consider the long-term benefits and potential cost savings.
  • Add-on accessories 
    From lights and automatic openers to keypads and security sensors, these add-ons contribute to the overall cost. These accessories offer convenience and increased safety, but it is vital to consider their impact on the project budget. Once you decide on the type of replacement you require, it’s time to finalize between DIY or professional installation. Let’s head to the section to learn more about the two.

DIY vs. Professional Garage Door Replacement Cost

When replacing a garage door, homeowners often face a common dilemma: should they attempt a DIY project or hire a professional? While DIY projects may be cost-effective, there are certain situations where it is better to leave the job to the experts. Let’s find out which one is better for you and the costs associated with them.

For DIY jobs, your main cost is simply the door price you select. You may think that the overall expense is significantly reduced by eliminating labor costs, but that is not that case. You may have to invest in professional tools to streamline the process. Not having the right tools can affect the quality and longevity of the installation. 

So, professional assistance is a must to carry out garage door replacement. They have the necessary expertise and knowledge to handle complicated installations. From connecting lifting motors to handling springs, professionals have the experience and resources to complete the job quickly and efficiently.

As per the national average, the labor cost is between $200 – $500 or more, and may vary according to your location. To know the exact pricing, we recommend you collect quotes from the best contractors available in your area.

Can You Save On Garage Door Replacement Costs?

If you’re wondering if you can save on garage door replacement costs, the answer is a resounding yes. By being smart and proactive, you can make significant savings without compromising on the quality of your garage door. Let’s explore some ways in this section. 

  • Choose A Basic Style
    As we discussed above, there are various types of garage doors to choose from. While fancy designs and customization options may be appealing, they can come with a hefty price tag. If you’re on a budget, consider opting for a basic style.  These are typically simpler in design and made from standard materials. You can expect to get security and functionality as per your requirements, significantly low costs, and a reliable garage door.
  • Purchase Materials From the Supplier
    Another way to save on garage door replacement costs is by purchasing raw materials directly from the supplier. By cutting out the intermediary, you can eliminate additional costs and markups. Conduct research to find reputable suppliers in your area and inquire about purchasing materials from them.
  • Take Advantage Of Home Warranty
    Home warranties cover repairs and replacements in your home, including major appliances and systems. Various top home warranty companies offer garage door coverage under basic plans. If you have a home warranty, it’s worth checking if it covers garage doors. If covered, you can save on replacement costs by utilizing your warranty.  Check the terms and conditions of your home warranty to understand what is covered and what isn’t. Lastly, contact your warranty provider to initiate the claim process and take advantage of the coverage.


When choosing a new garage door, we advise you to consider your basic requirements, climatic conditions in your location, and budget. This way, you can make an informed decision. Lastly, use your home warranty wisely to save on your garage door replacement costs. So, roll up your sleeves because it’s time to get a new garage door. 

Top home warranty Companies

related articles