New Mexico Home Warranty Companies
Check out the list of the best New Mexico home warranty companies. Choose the right plan for yourself by checking out the parameters of this list, i.e. the premiums, deductibles, ratings etc. HomeWarrantyReviews.com has thousands of customer reviews to help you know about the quality of service. A home warranty plan is the ideal way to keep expenses on repairs and replacements of household systems and appliances to a minimum. You can get a home warranty in New Mexico at an average premium of $318.98 and an average deductible of $40.55. Get a free home warranty quote from any company of your liking!
A Glimpse At Average Premium In New Mexico
Coverage in New Mexico (NM) major towns:
Alamogordo | Albuquerque | Clovis |
Farmington | Hobbs | Las Cruces |
Rio Rancho | Roswell | Santa Fe |
Population : 2,056,349
Don't Let Unexpected Appliance Failures Break You!
Do You Need a Home Warranty in New Mexico?
![]() |
American Home Shield (AHS) |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
Based on 13,849 Reviews
|
|
![]() |
![]() |
Choice Home Warranty |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
Based on 6,993 Reviews
|
|
|
![]() |
The Home Service Club |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
Based on 1,906 Reviews
|
|
![]() |
![]() |
Select Home Warranty |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
Based on 4,346 Reviews
|
|
|
![]() |
Total Home Protection |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
Based on 722 Reviews
|
|
New Mexico Home Warranty Companies Reviews

Douglas Holtsoi, Farmington
On Nov 24, 2020
American Home Shield (AHS)





I recently had some problems with my heater in my home. I called AHS and on this matter and they quickly contacted a local plumbing and heating company in my area and I started to work with them. I was amazed how much AHS invested in my heating problem, more than I had pondered on. The work was quickly done by the local company and now none of my family members do not have to worry about our heating going out in the middle of winter. I compliment both AHS and the local company for their help and concern. Thank you once again

David Pinckney, Clovis
On Oct 30, 2020
American Home Shield (AHS)





Absolutely terrible!! If I could give negative stars I would. First off they took forever to decide to replace my AC. They chose a local company with terrible ratings. I\'ve been back and forth with the local company that doesn\'t want to show up to install equipment. When I ask for a different company to be given the contract I get put on hold for literally hours and nothing comes of it. Not to mention they keep terrible records. I was asked 2 months ago if I wanted a replacement or cash pay out and I said replacement. Now the day that the local company is supposed to install the unit AHS still doesn't know that the install is what I chose! Also if you decide to get a cash payout they will only pay you the cost of install that they pay the local company. AHS orders the unit and sends to your local company to install. So lets just say you want to have a proper 5 ton unit installed in place of the existing undersized 4 ton unit. You will not pay the couple hundred dollar difference in cost between the two, you will only get reimbursed the install cost and have to shell out over $5K more out of pocket. Absolutely garbage overall. Also, good luck getting any correct information from their call center in the Philippines. They do not care about the customer and do nothing to help the situation, and of course there's no way to get ahold of an American here in the states that actually cares.

Florine Gutierrez, Albuquerque
On Oct 07, 2020
American Home Shield (AHS)





The techs came in on time right at 11 checked out the faucets and got right to it. They knew what they were doing, Also the heating maintenance was done.

Brian Stephenson, Rio Rancho
On Sep 22, 2020
American Home Shield (AHS)





The contractor was professional and went the extra mile to insure that we were satisfied with the job they did. Only issue was the time it took. No hot water for 7 days

Ryan Watson, Santa Fe
On Sep 18, 2020
American Home Shield (AHS)





Seller provided the home warranty for my new house. The water heater started leaking the week I moved in and the floor drain underneath it was clogged! American Home Shield sent a local plumber who got the drain unglogged and water heater replaced the next day!

Marianne Wright, Rio Rancho
On Aug 08, 2020
American Home Shield (AHS)





Great company, also came thru with a great contractors - I have had two issues , one with my heating ,air system , one with my oven, both were repaired promptly and professionally with know companies in my area. I would recommend American Home Shield!

Shirley salas, Albuquerque
On Jul 27, 2020
American Home Shield (AHS)





The service was excellent. The service man answered my questions and gave me some great info about my A/C. He went up on the roof and fixed the problem. He also showed me hoe to clean the condensation line. He was very professional. I would use this company again.

Jay Rodenbeck, Albuquerque
On Jul 22, 2020
American Home Shield (AHS)





My AC repairman did an excellent job and was very expeditious, we were very happy with our repair. He also gave us very valuable tips on how to maintain our air conditioner ourselves

Morgan Topp, Las Cruces
On Jun 12, 2020
American Home Shield (AHS)





This was A fast and easy experience. We put the order for the work on a Sunday night, and Monday morning they called and said they would be there between 10 and 11 AM. The technician came at 10:04 AM, I figured out what it was and repaired it and was on his way within an hour. He was very friendly and wore a mask inside and while working. We are very happy with this result.

JoLynn Kniffin, Rio Rancho
On Jan 08, 2020
American Home Shield (AHS)





I had 2 claims just before the Christmas holiday, our microwave stopped working and water heater started running out of hot water more quickly than usual - so not super critical items, livable. The microwave was quickly diagnosed and was approved for replacement, it took several weeks for it to be ordered, received and installed but we are grateful it was covered. The water heater took 2 visits (and a couple of weeks) from the plumber before they determined it should be replaced but the installation was then scheduled quickly and efficiently. Overall, we are very pleased with AHS, just took some time and patience to get to the end result.

Monteen Amezquita, Albuquerque
On Nov 18, 2019
American Home Shield (AHS)





Appliance repair guy was fantastic. He diagnosed the problem and the next day came back and had it fixed.

Yvonne M Coats, Albuquerque
On Oct 30, 2019
American Home Shield (AHS)





When we had our gas heat turned on earlier in October, we had the company check out all the gas appliances. They discovered excess carbon monoxide being released from the oven when it was turned on and suggested we repair or replace the stove. American Shield answered my call immediately and found a repair service in my area. Everything worked precisely as the AHS representative told me it would, and the service company was excellent. I was impressed by AHS's service and by the quality of the repair service.

Ashley Romero, Albuquerque
On Sep 23, 2019
Lowe's Appliance Extended Warranty





HIGHLY recommend Lowe\'s Extended Warranty!! Prompt and friendly service!!

Jennifer Stephens, Alamogordo
On May 18, 2019
American Home Shield (AHS)





So far, so good! I purchased an American Home Shield warranty when escrow closed on my new home. Good thing, as I found out a few days later that the refrigerator I inherited didn\'t work properly. I made a call to American Home Shield and they had a repairman here the following day. It took a few days to get the parts ordered, but the refrigerator is running great now. I paid a lot less for the home warranty than it would have cost to buy a new fridge. I did have one issue that turned out to be a misunderstanding; I was under the impression that re-keying the locks was included with the purchase of the plan, but it wasn't. Instead of paying the service fee, I went to my local home improvement store and bought new locksets as it was more cost effective to do the job myself. Overall, I'm very happy with the purchase of the home warranty; I'm covered on heating, cooling, plumbing, and all of my major appliances (with the exception of my R.O. system), all for under $600/year.

Mary Anne DeBarbrie, Santa Teresa
On May 07, 2019
American Home Shield (AHS)





I have used AHS for many years for my house in New Mexico and I have been very happy with them. Last year I bought a home in Texas and have AHS on it too. Outstanding service and they stay with you until the problem is resolved.

James Phillips, Albuquerque
On Apr 22, 2019
American Home Shield (AHS)





I have used American Home Shield to repair my air conditioner last year and my furnace this year. they were absolutely easy to deal with and the repairs were done well and timely. AHS followed up with me to make sure everything was good. AHS is probably one of the best companies I have ever dealt with and I highly recommend them

Gall, Albuquerque
On Apr 08, 2019
General Home Warranty





Melissa the reception person acts like she is a qualified contractor to deny claims. She asked for proof of home inspection that clearly states the warranty covers, & without sending someone still tries to deny coverage. I am calling the AG, BBB, & a lawyer! Screw this fraud company!

Owen Pena, Albuquerque
On Apr 01, 2019
American Home Shield (AHS)





AHS is an great company to do business with. They are extremely professional in every aspect of the process. I have used them 5 separate times for appliance and pool plumbing issues. All five times ended in positive results. The companies AHS works with have all been very professional and respond very fast. I highly recommend AHS!!

Brendan Gunning, Albuquerque
On Feb 09, 2019
General Home Warranty





This company is a borderline scam. I had a roof leak on Oct 23 2018 which I reported that same night. I received a phone call back shortly after saying a roofer would be out in 7-10 days because they were busy due to bad weather. I follow up in a week, again same thing 7-10 days. A MONTH LATER, November 28th, I get a call from GHW saying their roofer no longer works on tile roofs and a different roofer would call me within 48 hours. Never got a call. I called back 5 more times and eventually got a call from a roofer on December 21st but I was out of town and had to schedule a visit later. The roofer comes over January 8th and looks at the roof, finds where the leak is coming from, and calls GHW to explain the problem. I follow up with the roofer January 16th, he says he hasn't heard anything from GHW. I've called GHW probably 20 times over the course of this incident. Due to these absurd delays, each time it rains and leaks it drips into my kitchen ceiling which is now damaged. I filed a complaint with the BBB and GHW responded that "bad weather has backed up roofers both estimating and making repairs" and that they had responded to the roofer approving the repair. Excuse me, it's been 3 months - we haven't had 3 months straight of bad weather. I've contacted multiple other roofers who all said they could have an estimate in 1-3 days and repair in 1-2 weeks unless it was a complicated repair, which this isn't. I could have had this repaired in 2 weeks, but it's taken GHW 3 months and counting. GHW has delayed and delayed, and their negligence has caused damage to my kitchen ceiling which I'm sure they won't repair either. This is, without a doubt, the worst company I have ever dealt with in my life. This home warranty was just included in the closing of my home and I didn't think twice about it. Do your homework, read reviews, and choose a home warranty company with decent reviews. GHW is a scam, avoid at all costs.

Alana Rodis, Gallup
On Jan 09, 2019
American Home Shield (AHS)





My husband and I were buying a new home when he suggested purchasing a home warranty. I researched various home warranty providers and AHS was, by far, the best option I found. Still, I was skeptical of "wasting" money on something I didn\'t think we would need. Boy, was I wrong - our furnace died and AHS covered the cost and replacement of a brand new motor IN FULL. This has more than paid for itself, and we are so appreciative of AHS's customer service, timeliness, and use of reputable vendors. Very highly recommended.

Mike Griffiths, Albuquerque
On Dec 15, 2018
American Home Shield (AHS)





I rest easy and have continually used the service it is a great peace of mind to have repairs done with high costs Best investment Ive made in years

Amanda Charlson, Las Cruces
On Dec 12, 2018
American Home Shield (AHS)





We have been dealing with American Home Shield since June 2018 regarding an AC issue on a home that we manage. The issue was repaired after two months of dealing with an unlicensed contractor that they hired. We have now been dealing with the most awful and unhelpful customer service since September in an effort to get reimbursed for something that they agreed to in writing. We have been on hold literally for hours at a time only to have nothing resolved each time we call. Every person we speak to has a response different from what we were told before. Our office staff has spent about 40 hours since June dealing with this issue. It's unbelievable to me that they are still in business!! I was just on hold for 51 minutes and when they transferred me to yet another department, a message told me they could not help me at this time and to follow the normal procedures for my request and then they hung up!!! As a property manager, I will never recommend American Home Shield to anyone.

Breanna Cordova, Albuquerque
On Dec 04, 2018
General Home Warranty





I absolutely regret using this company. Got ignored for months. When I would call to follow up, they lady answering the phone kept asking if I wanted to make a claim. The roofer finally called and said he was “just doing it to make me happy.” He left damage to the inside of my home. I spoke with a manager that did not care and gave me a wrong email address to send my complaint to. I called to verify that email and was told someone would call me back. That never happened. After all the that, my roof is still leaking and I was told once again someone would call me back.

Charmaine C, Albuquerque
On Aug 25, 2018
American Home Shield (AHS)





Horrible plumbers. The last time i used them they did not resolved the plumbing problem and STILL WAS CHARGED 75.00 by Home Shield. I had no cold water - they put in a new cartridge and nothing changed but charged me anyway and said they would come back but no-one ever called. They tried to make me look foolish with all kinds of excuses. GEE!!!! i figured it out by myself. The water heater was not turned on the whole way! They told me IT WAS COLD WATER when it was lukewarm and said they could do nothing more for me. They gave horrible service the whole way through. What a waste of money. If the plumbers were not so AWFUL, i might have renewed HS for a second year. I only used home shield for the plumbing. Nothing else was wrong.

Bridget L Sipes, Albuquerque
On Aug 01, 2018
American Home Shield (AHS)





Could improve the time you have to wait to speak with a customer service representative
Reviews For Home Warranty Companies in New Mexico
The services and plans offered by the various home warranty companies have been reviewed on our site. You can decide whether a particular company’s services are what you wish for. If you have a home warranty experience to share, please feel free to write a review.
How to Make the Most of Your Plan
When choosing a home warranty plan consider the aspects of plan coverage, company reputation and contract cost. These factors are important to make a wise choice.