We maintain complete transparency with the readers on our website. The company rankings on our site are independent of any marketing relationships that we may hold with a home warranty company. We may receive compensation for receiving quotes or placing advertisements. However, this does not affect a company's rankings. Companies are ranked solely on the basis of consumer reviews and ratings received from home warranty users.

*The lead information obtained will be sent to the respective companies as selected by the readers. However, the lead will be shared with a similar company if the selected company either doesn't participate in Leads Program or doesn't respond.


We maintain complete transparency with the readers on our website. The company rankings on our site are independent of any marketing relationships that we may hold with a home warranty company. We may receive compensation for receiving quotes or placing advertisements. However, this does not affect a company's rankings. Companies are ranked solely on the basis of consumer reviews and ratings received from home warranty users.

*The lead information obtained will be sent to the respective companies as selected by the readers. However, the lead will be shared with a similar company if the selected company either doesn't participate in Leads Program or doesn't respond.

Home  /   Us   /  indiana
last_updated_date Updated on January 3, 2023
last_updated_date Updated on January 3, 2023
Best Home Warranty Companies In Indiana 2023

Best Home Warranty Companies In Indiana 2023

Temperatures in Indiana fluctuate heavily from 10°F in winters to 90°F in Summers. These severe fluctuations can strain home systems and appliances due to overuse, resulting in breakdowns. We’ve listed the best home warranty companies in Indiana to help residents safeguard their household and finances by investing in an ideal home warranty plan.

Disclaimer: We facilitate quotes from reputable home warranty providers and may earn a commission, but that does not influence our evaluation process to produce unbiased reviews.

The costs of repairs and replacements of household items In Indiana without a home warranty can be expensive. As a homeowner, investing in a home warranty will save you money on appliances and systems maintenance.

Indiana Home Repair And Replacement Cost

This section will cover the average repair and replacement cost of major home systems and appliances used in an Indianan household. 


Now that you are familiar with how costly it is to maintain your home, it is wise to go for a home warranty. 

  • 90-day service guarantee
  • Two comprehensive plans
  • Covers 46 states
$200 Off + 2 Months Free Coverage
  • 30-day labor guarantee
  • 90-day parts guarantee
  • $3k dollar limits on each item
1st month free + Free roof coverage
  • Multi-year plans
  • Same-day response on claims
  • B rating from BBB
$150 off + Free roof coverage + 2 months free

Top Home Warranty Companies In Indiana

Go through some of Indiana's top-rated home warranty companies in this section.

Premium (Monthly)
Coverage Limit
Workmanship Guarantee
Covers Pre-Existing Conditions

An existing malfunction in any system or appliance before the coverage begins on a home warranty plan refers to a pre-existing condition. A unknown pre-existing condition is one that cannot be detected during the routine maintenance/inspection or is unknown to the homeowner. To know more, you can refer to our detailed article on does home warranty cover pre-existing conditions.

Choice Home Warranty
$46-$55 Upto $3K/item 60-Day No No Extra Fees For Coverage Of Up To 5000 Sq. Ft. Homes
American Home Shield (AHS) VIEW MORE $29 - $99 $4k-$5k 30-Day Yes (Unknown) Hvac Tune-Ups
Select Home Warranty
$44 - $47 $3k/Item 90-Day No Free Roof Leak Coverage
Liberty Home Guard
$50-$60 $2k/Item 60-Day Yes (Unknown) Add-Ons include pest control
First American Home Warranty VIEW MORE $47-$87 $2,500 30-Day No Unlimited Service Calls Over The Year
Cinch Home Services
$38 - $66 $10,000 180-Day Yes (Unknown) $25 Credit Towards A/C

Best Home Warranty Companies In Indiana: Reviewed

By reading this section, you will know about Indiana’s top home warranty companies, their plans, pricing, and much more. 

Choice Home Warranty

four_star4.0 / 5
Free coverage for a month + roof coverage

Choice Home Warranty has been in the business for over two decades and is known for its easy-to-understand plans. The company is a good option as it has a lower deductible and affordable premium, along with 24/7 customer service. 


  • 30 days repair guarantee for a repaired item
  • Provides free coverage for roof leak


  • Doesn’t offer the freedom to choose your own technician

Plans and Coverage 

Choice Home Warranty offers only two plan choices to the homeowners- Basic Plan and Total Plan. Both plans include crucial home systems and appliances. While the Basic Plan covers 14 items, including the heating and plumbing systems. The Total Plan covers 18 items, including ductwork and an air conditioning system. 


The Basic Plan is around $46 monthly, and the Total Plan is around $54. Your deductible can also range from $75-$150. 

$46.83 $46.83 Basic Plan
$54.75 $54.75 Total Plan

Exclusions and Coverage Limit 

In the Choice Home Warranty’s contract, there is a limit of $3000 for repairs, replacement, or diagnosis of included items. 

Here are some other exclusions: 

  • No coverage for damages due to neglect, unforeseen circumstances, or lack of maintenance.
  • Pre-existing conditions are also not covered.

American Home Shield (AHS)

four_star4.0 / 5
Cashback, Amazon gift cards, etc., on referrals.

American Home Shield has been in the home warranty industry since 1971. It is popular amongst homeowners because of its unlimited coverage (unknown pre-existing conditions included) and comprehensive plans. They can be an option for Indianans looking for unlimited coverage at nominal prices. 


  • Unlimited coverage for systems
  • Undetectable pre-existing conditions covered


  • 30 days workmanship guarantee

Plans and Coverage 

American Home Shield provides three plan options: ShieldSilver, ShieldGold, and ShieldPlatinum. ShieldSilver covers 14 items, including but not limited to a garage door opener, water heater, and air conditioner. ShieldGold includes 23 items, including a refrigerator, doorbell, and chimes. Lastly, ShieldPlatinum is a comprehensive plan including items from both the plans and some additional items. 


American Home Shield plans can start from $19 to $70 monthly, depending on the chosen deductible options: $75, $100, and $125. You will have to pay a lower premium if you choose the higher deductible. 

$19.99 $19.99 ShieldSilver
$39.99 $39.99 ShieldGold
$69.99 $69.99 ShieldPlatinum

Exclusions and Coverage Limit 

Here are some of the exclusions according to the American Home Shield contract:

  • Mold, rot, fungus, and damage due to pests;
  • Regular maintenance, flues, exhaust lines, and venting; 
  • Chimneys, cosmetic damage, home management systems, monitoring systems. 

There are also dollar limitations on how much the company is liable for repairing and replacing any included item. In the contract, the company has stated that you can get unlimited dollar limits on systems and $6k on appliances. 

Select Home Warranty

threehalf_star3.5 / 5
$150 off + two months of free coverage + free roof coverage

Select Home Warranty offers affordable plans, exclusive deals, and services matching the industry standard. Additionally, their nationwide presence and free roof-leak coverage make them worthy of consideration for home warranty customers in Indiana. 


  • Free roof-leak coverage offered
  • Guarantee of 90-day on workmanship


  • Lower caps on coverage

Plans and Coverage 

Select Home Warranty is known to offer three plans: Bronze Care, Gold Care, and Platinum Care along with free roof coverage in each plan. The Bronze Care includes major appliances, and the Gold Care plan includes major systems. However, if you are looking for a combined plan, Platinum Care offers holistic systems and appliance coverage.


The cost of Bronze Care and Gold Care is $45 monthly, while Platinum Care is $50 per month. The service fee can vary depending on your location from $60-$100.

$45.67 $45.67 Bronze Care
$45.67 $45.67 Gold Care
$50.25 $50.25 Platinum Care

Exclusions and Coverage Limit

The Select Home Warranty has a coverage cap of $2k per home appliance or system included in the plan. 

Some of the other exclusions include the following things:

  • Damages caused due to abuse, corrosion, improper installation, rust
  • Unknown or known pre-existing conditions 
  • Items that are damaged because of Acts of Nature 
  • Parts of any covered item
  • Damages because of water, fire, or mold spores. 

Liberty Home Guard

fourhalf_star4.5 / 5
$200 off + two bonus months + free roof leak protection

Liberty Home Guard is a popular choice among homeowners as it has comprehensive coverage for systems and appliances. They offer optional add-on coverage for over 38 items, including pest control. Their live-in-chat feature makes it easy for homeowners to make a complaint 24/7. 


  • A live chat option for the users
  • Pest control as an add-on option for the homeowners


  • Doesn’t serve Washington and Wisconsin

Plans and Coverage 

Liberty Home Guard offers three plans to its homeowners: Systems Guard, Appliance Guard, and Total Home Guard. As the name suggests, Systems Guard includes major home systems, and Appliance Guard includes major home appliances. Lastly, Total Home Guard includes systems & appliances and additional add-on options.


Liberty Home Guard plans can range from $60 to $69 every month, and if you choose any optional items, it can go up to $195. You will also have to pay a $90 deductible on every visit. 

$64.99 $64.99 Systems Guard
$59.99 $59.99 Appliance Guard
$69.99 $69.99 Total Guard

Exclusions and Coverage Limit 

Liberty Home Guard excludes the following from coverage 

  • Known and unknown pre-existing conditions
  • Cosmetic defects, glass parts, and components, any costs related to refrigerant 
  • Electronic, vents, chimneys
  • Costs for construction, Acts of God, electrical failure, and more 

The Liberty Home Guard’s annual coverage for diagnosing, repairing, or replacing included items during the tenure is $2000/item. 

First American Home Warranty

threehalf_star3.1 / 5
First Class Upgrade option + $25 Amazon gift card

First American Home Warranty is famous for its low monthly premiums, 24/7 customer service availability, and experience of over four decades. The company has a B rating from the BBB, making it a popular option for homeowners in Indiana.


  • Includes pest control
  • Affordable plan pricing


  • Basic plan doesn’t include plumbing or electrical systems

Plans and Coverage 

First American Home Warranty offers two plans to homeowners- Basic Plan and Premier Plan. The Basic Plan includes all the essential home appliances, while the Premier Plan has the major systems and appliances such as a washer, refrigerator, and electrical system. 


First American Home Warranty’s Basic Plan starts from $33 per month, while the Premium Plan starts from $45 per month. You will also have to pay a deductible fee of $85 every time the technician visits your home.

$33 $33 Basic Plan
$45 $45 Premier Plan

Exclusions and Coverage Limit 

First American Home Warranty has an average coverage cap of $3500 per system and $1500 per appliance in their plan. Additionally, here are some of the exclusions from their plans:

  • Pre-existing conditions 
  • Space heaters, vents, fuel storage tanks
  • Accessories, shelves, digital meters, hinges
  • Doorbells and lock assemblies  

Cinch Home Services

twohalf_star2.9 / 5
Two bonus months or $50 Off depending on the coverage

Cinch Home Services has served over a million customers over the last four decades. The highlight of the company’s  is the 180-day workmanship guarantee it offers, which is higher than the industry average. Also, the company covers ‘water sensors for leak detection’ free of cost with any of their plans.


  • 180-day workmanship guarantee
  • Free water sensor to detect leaks


  • Lower coverage caps

Plans and Coverage 

Cinch Home Services offers three different home warranty plans: Appliances Plan, Built-in Systems Plan, and Complete Home Plan. The Appliance Plan covers major home appliances and the Built-in Systems Plan covers the prominent systems. Complete Home Plan is an extensive plan including both home systems and appliances. 


The plans of this company can range between $27 to $39 every month. Depending on the selected plan, the service fee or deductible can be $75, $100, and $150 each. 

$27.99 $27.99 Appliances Plan
$32.99 $32.99 Systems Plan
$39.99 $39.99 Complete Plan

Exclusions and Coverage Limit 

Cinch Home Services has a coverage cap of up to $2k/item for both home appliances and systems. Here are some of the other exclusions:

  • Damages due to pet, fire, flood, earthquake, and more
  • Flues, chimney, misuse, and neglect, venting, and exhaust lines
  • Damages because of water pressure, mold, mildew, bacteria, and virus, mildew, mold

Annual Cost of Home Maintenance In Top Indiana Cities 

In this section, you will get information about home maintenance prices in major cities of Indiana.



Homeowners have a lot of expenses not limited to mortgage, taxes, and utilities. Unfortunately, home appliances and home systems are prone to a lot of damage and can demand unexpected repairs and replacement. As Indiana experiences all four seasons, it can be challenging to maintain all the appliances and systems yourself. 

Here is a breakdown of why it is vital to get a home warranty in major cities of Indiana. 

Indianapolis, Indiana

Indianapolis is a great place to live, but the cost of living is higher than the state average. Major services in Indianapolis are 4% more expensive, making it difficult to get affordable repairs and maintenance. To save yourself from any expensive repairs or replacements, you should invest in a home warranty.

Bloomington, Indiana

The cost of living in Bloomington is a whopping 11% higher than Indiana’s average. Also, the prolonged winters in the city make it very difficult to maintain your home appliances and systems. Therefore, many homeowners in Bloomington have turned to home warranty services for monetary savings and quick services in case of unexpected breakdowns.

Evansville, Indiana

Even though housing expenses are 24% lower as compared to the national average, homeowners in Evansville will still have to pay 13% more for major home maintenance. Many homeowners in the city have, time and again, cut down on their annual maintenance budget with comprehensive home warranty plans.

South Bend, Indiana

Even though living in South Bend is affordable compared to the other regions, the cost of living has consistently risen over the years. The handyman services come at an extra price if a major appliance and system breakdown can get expensive. So, it is wise to save your budget from such harsh surprises and invest in one of the home warranties in Indiana.

Why Purchase A Home Warranty In Indiana?

Indiana summers are hot and humid, while the winters are frigid. The winter temperature can go as low as 15°F or -10°C, and in summers, the temperature can reach up to 90°F or 32°C. This temperature change can significantly impact the functioning of major home systems and appliances, thus contributing to wear and tear.

Here is a breakdown of the weather conditions in Indiana:

AverageAverage Rainfall

37-47 inches/Year

Average SunlightAverage Sunlight

186 Sunny Days/Year

General Climate ConditionsGeneral Climate Conditions
  • Warm Summers
  • Temperate Winters
Tropical CyclonesTropical Cyclones


Such changing conditions can cause a lot of normal wear and tear during the year. That is why investing in a home warranty is always a great idea to save your budget from any unexpected surprises.

Common Home Repair Problems Faced By Indiana Homeowners

Let’s look at the common problems faced by Indiana homeowners:

Problems With Heating/Cooling System:

Some common problems homeowners can face with heating and cooling systems are no proper maintenance and aging components. You will need to spend thousands of dollars to get the air conditioning or the heating system repaired or replaced, depending on the problem.

Problems With Heating/Cooling System:
Problems With The Roof

Problems With The Roof

There can be roof problems as Indiana experiences winter snow. The handymen can cost thousands of dollars to fix this problem.

Issues With The Electrical Systems

One of the main problems that every homeowner faces is with the electrical systems. Hiring an electrician can cost up to $300 or more, mainly depending on the severity of the problem.

Issues With The Electrical Systems

Plumbing Issues

Plumbing defects are one of the common problems across Indiana. The repairs for this problem can cost somewhere from $50-$200.

Best Home Warranty Companies In Indiana: Comparison

Here is a comparison of the best home warranty companies in Indiana to help you make the right decision:

Home Warranty Regulations In Indiana

In Indiana, a home warranty company gets authorized by The Indiana Department of Insurance. The organization properly monitors the purchase and use of insurance products and a home warranty to keep Indiana homeowners safe. You should always check that the home warranty company is licensed and secured by the Department. 

Bottom Line: 

Getting a home warranty will provide peace of mind and protect your budget. Get a few quotes for choosing the ideal home warranty in Indiana. It will help you compare coverage and pricing of various companies’ plans, thus ensuring you get the best deal.

You May Also Interested In These States

 Best Companies In California

Best Companies In California

It is difficult for most of your home appliances and systems to survive the heat of California. If a..

Best Companies In Georgia

Best Companies In Georgia

The north of Georgia usually freezes in the winter, while the south experiences unbearable hot and h..

 Best Companies In Texas

Best Companies In Texas

The hot Texas summers can put a strain on your air conditioner as well as other systems and applianc..


Recent Articles

Home appliances such as microwaves, refrigerators, and dishwashers hav ...

The dishwasher is among the most regularly utilized appliances at home ...

Your air conditioner becomes a lifesaver when the sweltering summer he ...

Articles For Indiana Homeowners


How Long Does The Home Warranty Last On The House?

Generally, a home warranty lasts for one year on the house. The home warranty company provides a yearly renewable service agreement.

What’s The Best Time To Buy A Home Warranty?

Issues with systems and appliances can occur throughout their lifetime, so it is wise to invest in a home warranty plan if you don’t have one at any given time.

Do Home Warranty Companies Cover Existing Problems?

American Home Shield, Cinch Home Services, and Liberty Home Guard are some of the companies that cover existing problems. But, reading the company’s service contract will often provide a clear picture w.r.t. the coverage details.

Which Is A Better Investment? Home Warranty Or Home Insurance

Both home warranty and home insurance are quite different and serve different purposes. While the home warranty covers systems and appliances damaged due to wear and tear, the home insurance covers damage to the property. As both serve various purposes, most homeowners tend to purchase both of them.

What Are Deductibles In A Home Warranty?

A deductible is a minimum charge a homeowner must pay for every technician’s visit. The deductibles can range from $50 to $125, depending on the home warranty company.