We maintain complete transparency with the readers on our website. The company rankings on our site are independent of any marketing relationships that we may hold with a home warranty company. We may receive compensation for receiving quotes or placing advertisements. However, this does not affect a company's rankings. Companies are ranked solely on the basis of consumer reviews and ratings received from home warranty users.

*The lead information obtained will be sent to the respective companies as selected by the readers. However, the lead will be shared with a similar company if the selected company either doesn't participate in Leads Program or doesn't respond.

Home /  Home Maintenance / 12 Reasons to Replace Your Gutters
last_updated_date Last updated: January 24, 2019

Grab the best Home Warranty deals from the top rated companies


12 Reasons to Replace Your Gutters

PUBLISHED: November 12, 2018 6 MINS READ

When you look at the home guttering systems, they seem sturdier than they appear. But these gutters made from galvanized steel or aluminum last for two decades and the copper gutters can hold its own for half a century.

12 Reasons to Replace Your Gutters

These periods may not account for problems like fallen tree limbs or damage for ladders. You should not rely on gutters that are dysfunctional. But you don’t also want to rip down a perfectly-good set of gutters just because you may see a blemish or two. Here are 12 signs that you should look out for:

  1. Large Number of Cracks, Holes, or Rust Spots

    There are a few that use sealant and a little flashing to fix these cracks and holes. But if there are half a dozen sections that broken then you should opt for new gutters. Though a small crack is not a big deal, it can turn out to be bigger before you know it. What’s worse is allowing it to cause damage to your shingles above the gutters and fascia boards behind the gutters. Worst of all, the damage can extend to your foundation, which is exponentially more expensive than gutter repair or replacement.
  2. Several Broken Fasteners

    Fasteners are pieces of metal that hold your gutter to your roof and keep it in a level position. These pieces of metal ensure that your gutters are secure to the roof and keep it level. Even if there are a few fasteners, gutter repairs should be the solution. But if the problem persists then gutter replacement is the only option.
  3. Nails or Screws on the GroundNails or screws on the groundThere are times when nails or screws that fasten the gutter to the fascia can become loose. This is when replacing them is easy but repeated instances of the screws coming loose would mean that there is gutter wear. 
  4. Separated Gutters

    Gutters function if they are fastened together in a continuous channel. If they are separated from one another frequently then it’s time for a gutter replacement.
  5. Signs of Mildew or Pools of Water Surrounding the Foundation

    Though there maybe signs of mildew anywhere on your home, it can be quite alarming. But if you notice mildew or pools of water near the foundation then it means that you need to repair or replace gutters.In case gutter are dripping then you find pools of water or water around the foundation then it could be as simple as a clog that needs to be cleaned. But if it is a more complex problem then the gutter system needs changing. Water that collects near the foundation can be damaging and be an extremely expensive fix.
  6. Gutters Pulling Away From the Roof

    Use a hammer and push in the fasteners from time to time. But if the spaces continue to show between your roof line and the gutters then the fascia boards could be rotting. You should otherwise replace the gutters and this will fix the fascia problems along with giving you a new gutter.
  7. Sagging or Improperly-Pitched Gutters

    If there is a proper pitch which is not maintained along the gutter, then the water will pool in a few sections and spill over. You should consider to replace the gutters if you cannot fix this problem. One of the most surefire ways to determine if you should repair or replace gutters on your home is if they are sagging or pulling away from your home.The best thing is that you don’t need a ladder to notice this. You should know that your gutters should never pull away from your home or sag. If this is the case, then it can indicate your gutters are full of water, and the weight of the water is causing them to sag. A full gutter could mean that the debris is causing a blockage, the system is not draining well enough or the gutter system isn’t right for your home.
  8. Peeling Exterior PaintPeeling exterior paint
    Exterior paint peels away if the gutters pull away from the roof and water seeps down over the rear edge and onto the siding or trim. Peeling paint would usually mean that this is happening for a while and it makes sense to replace your gutters.The paint on your gutter is uniquely designed endure the standard wear and tear through the seasons. Unless your gutters are exceptionally old, orange flecks or peeling paint can be a beginning indicator of rust. This could also mean that it is retaining water continually. This problem stems from water not properly being removed by the gutter system or that cracks and other damage may be present.
  9. Dirt Channels or Pooling WaterDirt channels or pooling waterUsually after a rain, you will notice that water is spilling over your gutters. You should try to correct the problem but you should consider changing your gutters if the problem does not go away. 
  10. Water Marks or Water Damage Under the Gutters

    Once a year, you should make it a point to check your gutters especially on a day when it’s not rainy and quite sunny. Marks under your gutter can indicate water is either overflowing or leaking. If your Fascia board and Soffit is damaged then this is due to water intrusion.
  11. Eroded Landscaping

    You should ensure that your hard work makes your landscaping look good. If you must repeatedly invest time and money to repair water damage from malfunctioning gutters then you should know that it’s time that you change your gutters.
  12. Flooded BasementsFlooded basements
    When it comes to flooded basements, it could be based on the constantly pouring near the foundation that leaks into your basement which could really do some damage. While repairing your basement, you should go ahead and replace gutter.

What You Should Know About Gutters?

Here are some important questions that would help you know more about gutters and how it can be fixed:

How Much Does It Cost to Replace Gutters?

Usually, the average cost to install aluminum or galvanized gutters would be $4 to $9 per linear foot. You could choose vinyl gutters which are easier to install and cost $3 to $5 per linear foot. So for most homes, to install in the region for 125 to 200 feet of gutters it will cost $1050 to $2400.

How Do You Fix Guttering?

You should allow the insides of the gutters to dry out and brush the leaks seams clean and then add a layer of silicone-rubber caulking compound along the inside and outside to seal the leaks. Also, you should patch small holes with the roofing cement and use a putty knife to spread the cement around the hole.

How Do You Fix Loose Gutters?

Fixing Gutter Spikes

Take out the loose gutter spikes with the claw end of a hammer or pry bar. After which you should inspect them to determine if you need to buy new spikes. Replace the spikes if they are not threaded, or bent or damaged. Then you should thread the spikes into the old holes through the gutter and fascia. After which, you should add wood to make a tight fit.

Fixing Gutter Brackets

Fixing Gutter Brackets
You should remove the section of the sagging gutter from the lose gutter brackets. Remove the screws that hold the brackets to the fascia. Fill the screw holes with a weatherproof, exterior caulk and let the caulk dry completely. Next, you will have to drill new pilot holes for the brackets. This should be at the same height and angle as the old holes. This is to avoid shifting the pitch of the gutter, which can cause water to back up. Then you should attach the gutter brackets in the new holes and finally you should put the gutters back in the brackets.

Fixing Gutter Hangers

The first thing you should do is pull the hangers out from underneath the shingles or roofing material. Then you should replace damaged hangers. Finally, you should re-position undamaged hangers and move it to a better spot which is under the roofing material. This allows it to hold more securely.

How Do I Fix a Hole In My Gutter?

When it comes to fixing a leaky gutter, it is an inexpensive project that you can do yourself. In case its a metal gutter and it is rusted then you should patch it. If the hole is small, use plastic roofing cement. In case it is large, use a piece of galvanized metal flashing.

If you do not have the time for repairing then sign up for a home warranty.

Signing Up for a Home Warranty

You should constantly examine the overall condition of your home. Based on wear and tear, your home appliances and systems could wear out and this could lead to costly and expensive repairs. This means that you should do regular maintenance and make sure that this is done to every part of your home. This should be the case for the exterior of your home because the outer surface of the home is most subject to wear and tear.

Before signing up for a home warranty, you should know what it is. So what is a home warranty? Home warranty is a service contract that promises to repair or replace damaged appliances and systems, provided it meets the terms and conditions of the deal. On, you can get all the research, reviews and ratings of home warranty companies.

You should know that a warranty differs from a general homeowner’s insurance policy as it covers the repairs and replacements of damaged appliances and systems. While a homeowner’s insurance covers your home and its contents from uncertain events  such as loss, theft, and destruction.

Another thing is that a home warranty is different from a manufacturer’s warranty too. If your appliances and systems are no longer under the manufacturer’s warranty or you just want the added peace of mind, then yes a home warranty could save you money in the long run and cover the maintenance that your home insurance does not. You should know about these 10 things before you sign up for a home warranty.

A home warranty is perfect to give you peace of mind to the homeowner who otherwise has to pay unexpected repair bills especially in a house that he has already invested in. The benefits of a home warranty plan include saving cash on unexpected repairs, no running around to find contractors, renewable each year, major appliance covered.

Did you find this article helpful?   helpful yes icon | helpful no icon  

Thank you for your feedback!


Should You Renew Your Expiring Home Warranty? Should You Renew Your Expiring Home Warranty?
BY Victoria Baeker 6 MINS READ
Does a Home Warranty Plan Cover Plumbing Systems? Does a Home Warranty Plan Cover Plumbing Systems?
BY Victoria Baeker 6 MINS READ
Best Home Warranty Plans for First-Time Buyers Best Home Warranty Plans for First-Time Buyers
BY Victoria Baeker 6 MINS READ
chatbot icon